We make our ice creams and sorbets from scratch in our Bushwick (Brooklyn) laboratory. We have three batch freezers and we pasteurize all of our bases on site. This is truly small-batch ice cream.
All sales are final. If your ice cream doesn’t arrive frozen, we’ll reship the order at our cost. Need customer service? Contact hello@oddfellowsnyc.com
Yes, we offer e-gift cards for both the website and our scoop shops, as well as physical gift cards for the shop only.
For gift cards for our scoop shop, click HERE.
For gift cards for the website, click HERE.
Elvis, JoJo, Steve Winwood, Paula Abdul, Britney...B****, Nicki "The Queen" Minaj, Corey Hart, to start.
We follow all leading industry protocols to avoid cross-contamination in our production facility, but please note that flavors containing tree nuts are regularly produced there, and thus we cannot fully guarantee that any flavor does not contain trace amounts of nuts.
Yes, many of our ice creams and sorbets are gluten free. If you have a question about a particular flavor, please email us at hello@oddfellowsnyc.com.
Yes, we do offer vegan (dairy-free flavors). Vegan ice creams are also SOY-FREE! You can find them in our shops, and also available for national delivery HERE.
No, our ice cream is not yet certified as kosher.
No questions about the Monkey. Do not upset the monkey.
We ship to 48 states.
We pack our pints in an insulated box with enough dry ice to ensure that the goods stay frozen for the trip from Brooklyn to your home. We ship orders Monday. All orders ship out the day after your order is placed, and arrive the following day. So if you place an order on a Wednesday, it will ship out on Thursday, and arrive on Friday. You can also place an order and pick a calendar day in advance!
Currently all orders are for minimum 1 Collection or 5 tubs for Pick-Your-Pints.
We are aware of the environmental impact of shipping and packing materials and strongly encourage recycling or repurposing of the packaging. They make great coolers for chilling beverages in a park. Like… beer or wine… you know.
Before placing an order, please confirm that someone will be home to put the ice cream away in the freezer. If the recipient is not home to receive, there would be a charge for redelivery or reshipment.
Please ask your grocery store to stock OddFellows. And if that doesn't work, please email us at hello@oddfellowsnyc.com - we will do our best!
Technically, if frozen, ice cream lasts for months and months and months. But we recommend polishing it off in a week for best results. A lot of this depends on your freezer and how much moisture gets into the tub after first use.
